The short answer
Lucy Darling Little Rainbow is our top pick, with “four short prompts” a month; As You Grow is the minimal pick, “gender-neutral” by its publisher; Pearhead Chevron comes with an ink pad.
Our verdict
Our Top Picks
These are memory books you fill in; for books to read to a baby, see our best baby books. Here are eight, each with the cover we link and its maker’s claims, quoted.
Memory book finder
Find a memory book
Pick what you want and a price tier. The suggestion is our editorial starting point, drawn from the 8 books below; the claims are the makers'.
Compare the picks
Compare the 8 Baby Memory Books
Claims are the makers’.
Lucy Darling Little RainbowTop PickFirst year, short prompts, inclusiveWire-o$34.99
Evidence: owner reports, no independent test
As You GrowMinimal PickWriting, gender neutralHardcover$37.33 Prime
Evidence: owner reports, no independent test
Pearhead Chevron, GrayInk Pad PickPrints, budgetCloth binding$19.99 Prime
Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test
RubyRoo WoodlandPhoto Album PickPhotos, inclusive, holidaysHardcover$19.98
Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test
Promptly Childhood HistoryPregnancy to 18 PickWriting, long spanHardcover$39.97
Evidence: owner reports, no independent test
Paper Peony Baby Memory BookSpiral Scrapbook PickPhotos, scrapbookingGold spiral$23.31 Prime
Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test
two little dinos MinimalistSingle Parent PickSingle parents, inclusiveSewn binding$24.95
Evidence: maker specs only, no independent test
Always & ForeverAdoption PickAdoptionCloth cover$24.95 Prime
Evidence: owner reports, no independent test
How We Picked These Memory Books
How this guide was built
built from makers’ pages, Amazon listings and parents’ posts; we have not handled or filled in these books.
What each book had to have
- Guided prompts, in one cover checked against the maker’s page.
- In stock on Amazon on November 17, 2026, from Amazon.com, the maker’s store or (two little dinos) a seller at or below the maker’s list price.
- A CPSC recall search by maker and product words. We found no recall of these books or Pearhead’s ink pad.
Where the quotes come from
Where the quotes come from
Forum posts are dated by post, Reddit comments by thread start. We cite no editorial list as evidence; evidence is owners’ posts or maker specs.
Detailed Reviews
Lucy Darling Little Rainbow, Top Pick
Parents who want a short illustrated book they can keep up with in year one.
$34.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 18, 18:21 UTCVerdict
48 pages from “before birth to the fifth birthday”, with “Monthly pages with a photo and four short prompts” (Lucy Darling).
Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. What to Expect forum: Little Rainbow.
Its Amazon listing claims “extra-thick archival pages with no ink bleed-through” and “inclusive prompts for every kind of family”. There is a footprint page; no ink pad is listed. An owner of this theme on What to Expect (July 21, 2024): “We got the rainbow one and it’s 95% for baby’s first year with room for their first five birthdays and first day of school at the end of the book. So much more manageable then other memory books I’ve seen that are for the first five years of baby’s life, like no way am I going to consistently be filling that in for five years”.
Specs (linked: Little Rainbow)
- 9″ x 9″ (Lucy Darling)
Pros
- Four short prompts a month, by the maker
Cons
- Mostly a first-year book, per one owner
Who should buy it
Parents who want a short illustrated book they can keep up with in year one.
As You Grow, Minimal Pick
Verdict
A 160-page hardcover by Korie Herold with “Acid-free and archival paper” and “Lined pages for journal entries and letters for your child” (Paige Tate & Co).
Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. r/SingleMothersbyChoice: As You Grow.
The publisher also lists a “Lay-flat design” and “A pocket to safely store keepsakes”. An owner on r/SingleMothersbyChoice (thread started October 13, 2026): “I got ‘As You Grow’ by Kori Herold. It’s beautiful! There weren’t any explicit references to dad and there were blank spaces to accommodate a donor story if you wanted one. It’s also spiral bound so you could tear out or glue together pages if you wanted to.” The publisher does not name the binding.
Specs (linked: As You Grow, ISBN 978-1944515478)
- 9.75″ x 9.75″ trim (publisher)
Pros
- Lined pages for letters
Cons
- More writing than scrapbooking, by the publisher’s “minus all the time consuming scrapbooking”
Pearhead Chevron, Ink Pad Pick
Verdict
“50 guided journal pages” with an ink pad for a hand or footprint (Pearhead UK).
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Pearhead.
Pearhead’s Amazon text calls the pad “nontoxic, 100% baby safe”. Its FAQ: “Our ink pad is made of safe materials for baby and pet! While we do not recommend letting your baby or pet play with the ink pad unsupervised, if they do get ink on their skin or consume any it will not harm them.” Pearhead names no test or standard behind these claims in the pages we read. The FAQ says “Each ink pad can be used a maximum of 2 times”; the listing says “Three-time use maximum. For newborns only.” The FAQ says the pad typically fits from “a newborn” to “6 month old baby’s foot/hand print”.
Specs (linked: Chevron Baby Memory Book and Ink Pad, Gray)
- 9″ x 10.75″ (Pearhead)
Pros
- An ink pad in the box
Cons
- Pearhead’s pages disagree on the pad’s uses
- No US maker page; we did not open the listing’s instructions PDF
RubyRoo Woodland, Photo Album Pick
Verdict
“60 unique pages” from “pre-birth to year 5”, mostly 4 x 4 inch “square sized frames” (RubyRoo).
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: RubyRoo.
RubyRoo says “Inclusive language is designed for all families, including adoptive & LGBTQ” and claims “Thick, archival paper”. Its listing says it “doesn’t ask to record those hard to remember details”.
Specs (linked: RubyRoo Baby Memory Book, Woodland)
- Holiday pages “Designed for easy removal” (RubyRoo)
Pros
- Square frames RubyRoo says make it “easy to print photos off of social media”
Cons
- Holiday pages to remove if they don’t fit your family
Promptly Childhood History, Pregnancy to 18 Pick
Verdict
“254 pages of guided prompts” to age 18 that Promptly Journals says “can be completed in as little as one hour per year”.
Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. What to Expect forum: cover not stated.
An owner on What to Expect (July 21, 2024; cover not stated): “I’ve used it for my first and for number two! They have prompts and then a section to just write anything. They are monthly for the first year of life and then have sections for every year until your kid is 18!” and “They look nice and aren’t bulky as well.” Amazon’s linen listing mentions “an embossed leatherette cover”; Promptly sells this colour as linen.
Specs (linked: Dusty Rose, Linen)
- 6.25″ x 9.25″; “100 gsm” paper (Promptly)
Pros
- One book from pregnancy to 18
Cons
- Narrower than the other picks with a published size
Paper Peony Baby Memory Book, Spiral Scrapbook Pick
Verdict
A “Gold spiral interior, 98 baby book pages” with “detailed spreads for each of the first 12 months, followed by yearly entry sections through the age of 5” (Paper Peony Press).
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: Paper Peony Press.
The publisher lists a “Premium linen-wrapped hardcover” and a “Convenient keepsake envelope in the back”.
Specs (linked: The Baby Memory Book, ISBN 978-1952842160)
- 11.25″ x 10.5″ (publisher)
Pros
- Monthly spreads for year one
Cons
- A spiral binding, not a sewn spine
two little dinos Minimalist, Single Parent Pick
Verdict
A “60-page minimalist journal” its maker calls “single parent-friendly, LGBT friendly, as well as adoption friendly too” (two little dinos; Amazon listing).
Evidence: No independent test; maker specs. Source: two little dinos.
Amazon calls this colour Green; the maker calls it Olive. The maker lists a “Foot and handprint page (ink not included)”. The seller is Ri and E Stores LLC, shipped by Amazon.
Specs (linked: Minimalist Baby Memory Book, Olive)
- “sewn-binding pages and hardcover” (listing)
Pros
- Page titles worded for single parents, by the maker
Cons
- No acid-free or archival claim found
Always & Forever, Adoption Pick
Verdict
A 64-page cloth-covered book “Fitting for the adoption of both infants and older children” (Compendium).
Evidence: No independent test; owner reports. review on Compendium’s shop: Always & Forever.
A review on Compendium’s own shop (Kathryn L., April 23, 2024): “I looked long and hard for a baby book that would encapsulate all the memories that our adopted daughter might want to look back on or remember and came up short. I even purchased one or two but was never satisfied that our journey was accurately represented. This book, though, was amazing. I love the illustrations, the quotes and prompts. From an adoptive mama’s heart, thank you.”
Specs (linked: Always & Forever – Adoption Keepsake, ISBN 978-1970147650)
- 9″ x 9″ (Compendium)
Pros
- Prompts written for adoptive families
Cons
- Ends “to your first year together” (Compendium)
Which Memory Book for Which Family
Short on time
One parent on r/newborns (thread started May 23, 2026): “My problem is that most of the memory books ask for SO MUCH.” In our view, Lucy Darling and RubyRoo suit this. Lucy Darling keeps six of its 48 pages for five birthdays and the first day of school; for the first birthday, see our toys for 1-year-olds.
Inclusive and adoption books
two little dinos and RubyRoo name single-parent or adoptive families; Always & Forever is for adoption, and Promptly makes an adoption edition. Lucy Darling and two little dinos include a first-scribble page; see our crayons for kids.
Ink Pads and Recalls
Of the eight, only Pearhead lists an ink pad in the box. Pearhead’s FAQ does “not recommend” unsupervised play with it; we found no choking line in the FAQ or listing text we read. CPSC lists two Pearhead recalls, infant learning toy sets (2025) and Ubbi bath toys (2019); neither names a memory book or ink pad.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q. What is the best book to keep baby memories?
Our top pick is Lucy Darling Little Rainbow; for writing, As You Grow.
Q. What is a good book to record baby milestones?
Lucy Darling has 12 monthly pages; Paper Peony has spreads for each of the first 12 months.
Q. What are some good keepsake books for babies?
To 18, Promptly; for adoption, Always & Forever.
The bottom line
Final Verdict
Lucy Darling Little Rainbow (check price) is our top pick. As You Grow (check price) suits writers. Pearhead Chevron (check price) includes an ink pad.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
