Best Baby Shampoos for Newborns and Babies: Fragrance-Free and Scented

19 min read

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Read our affiliate disclosure.

The short answer

Babo Botanicals Sensitive Baby Fragrance-Free 2-in-1 Shampoo & Wash, 16 oz is BabyGearLab’s favorite and its maker says it suits babies “from birth on”; Aveeno Baby Daily Moisture Wash & Shampoo, 18 fl oz (check price) is a lightly scented, tear-free wash its maker calls “suitable for newborns”; and Aquaphor Baby Wash and Shampoo, 25.4 fl oz (check price) is a fragrance-free formula in the largest bottle here, with a pump.

Our verdict

Our Top Picks

This guide compares nine baby shampoos from nine brands that were new and in stock on Amazon when we checked on November 15, 2026: six sold as fragrance-free or unscented and three with a scent. Eight are 2-in-1 shampoo and body washes; Mustela’s is a scalp shampoo. For each one we set out what the maker says about tear-free formulas, ingredients left out, age and warnings, and what BabyGearLab’s hands-on review or Consumer Reports’ ingredient review found.

Shampoo finder

Find the right baby shampoo

Pick what matters most and a price tier. The suggestion is our editorial starting point, drawn from the nine shampoos below, not a test result.

What matters most to you?
Price tier

Tiers are relative to the shampoos in this guide; live prices are in the comparison table below.

Compare the picks

Compare the 9 Baby Shampoos

Claims are the makers’ unless a cell names another source.

Babo Botanicals Fragrance-Free 2-in-1 Baby Shampoo & Wash…Babo Sensitive Baby 2-in-1, 16 ozTop PickNewborns, fragrance free, sensitive skinFragrance freeFrom birth$20.00 Prime
Linked size16 fl oz
Tear-free claimNot claimed
Reviewed byBabyGearLab

Evidence: BabyGearLab, this exact model

The Honest Company Shampoo & Body Wash, Tear-Free, Lavender…Honest Shampoo & Body Wash, LavenderLavender ScentedWith scent, lavender, whole familyLavenderNone given$8.91 Prime
Linked size10 fl oz
Tear-free claimTear-free
Reviewed byBabyGearLab

Evidence: BabyGearLab, an earlier Honest lavender label (Truly Calming), 10 fl oz

Hello Bello Baby Shampoo & Body Wash, Gentle Fragrance…Hello Bello Shampoo & Wash, Fragrance FreeGluten and Dairy FreeFragrance free, gluten free, tear freeFragrance freeNone given$9.97 Prime
Linked size10 fl oz
Tear-free claimTear-free (maker badge)
Reviewed byBabyGearLab, CR

Evidence: BabyGearLab tested the earlier Extra Gentle formula, 10 fl oz

Aveeno Baby Daily Moisture Wash & Shampoo, Tear-Free, 18…Aveeno Baby Daily Moisture Wash, 18 ozOat Extract WashNewborns, with scent, tear freeLight scentNewborns$12.62 Prime
Linked size18 fl oz
Tear-free claimTear-free
Reviewed byCR

Evidence: Consumer Reports ingredient review, size not stated: Possible risks

Weleda Baby Calendula 2-in-1 Gentle Shampoo and Body Wash…Weleda Calendula 2-in-1, 6.8 ozCalendula FormulaWith scent, calendulaCalendulaNone given$10.41 Prime
Linked size6.8 fl oz
Tear-free claimGentle on eyes
Reviewed byBabyGearLab

Evidence: BabyGearLab, this exact model

Aquaphor Baby Body Wash and Shampoo, 25.4 FL OZ | Tear Free…Aquaphor Baby Wash and Shampoo, 25.4 ozLarge Pump BottleFragrance free, big bottle, pump bottleFragrance freeNone given$12.97 Prime
Linked size25.4 fl oz
Tear-free claimTear-free (listing)
Reviewed byBabyGearLab

Evidence: BabyGearLab, this exact model

CeraVe Baby 2-in-1 Wash & Shampoo with Vitamin E for Hair &…CeraVe Baby Wash & Shampoo, 8 ozEczema Association SealFragrance free, eczema sealFragrance freeNone given$8.97 Prime
Linked size8 fl oz
Tear-free claimTear-free
Reviewed byBabyGearLab, CR

Evidence: BabyGearLab, this exact model

Mustela Foam Shampoo for Newborns - Baby Shampoo for Cradle…Mustela Foam Shampoo for NewbornsCradle Cap FoamNewborns, fragrance free, cradle capFragrance freeFrom birth$16.50 Prime
Linked size5.07 fl oz
Tear-free claimGentle on eyes
Reviewed byCR

Evidence: Consumer Reports and Made Safe, this exact model

ATTITUDE Baby Shampoo & Body Wash Foaming 2-in-1…ATTITUDE Foaming 2-in-1, UnscentedUnscented Foam PumpUnscented, foam, pump bottleUnscentedNone given$8.99 Prime
Linked size10 fl oz
Tear-free claimNot claimed
Reviewed byCR

Evidence: Consumer Reports ingredient review of the earlier Baby Leaves name, size not stated

Prices as of Nov 15, 20:05 UTC

CR = Consumer Reports’ ingredient review with Made Safe (April 10, 2025).

Fragrance-Free, Scented and “Tear-Free”: What the Labels Mean

Fragrance-free or scented. Six of the nine are sold as fragrance-free or unscented. The Honest, Aveeno and Weleda washes have a scent: Honest’s ingredients list lavender oils, Aveeno’s list “Fragrance”, and Weleda’s list “Fragrance (Parfum)”; Weleda says the wash is “Free from synthetic preservatives, fragrances, colorants”. Consumer Reports’ advice: “Look for products that are fragrance-free or that disclose all fragrance ingredients.” BabyGearLab points out that “Being fragrance-free is not the same as being scent-free.”

Tear-free. Honest, Aveeno and CeraVe call their formulas tear-free, Hello Bello’s product page carries a “Tear-free” badge, and Aquaphor’s Amazon listing says tear-free too. Weleda and Mustela say “gentle on eyes”. Babo makes no tear-free claim and tells parents to “Avoid the eye area.” BabyGearLab’s view: “Although products often claim to be tear-free or equivalent, we believe this is a relative phrase and suggest avoiding eye contact as some babies could find the ingredients of any shampoo irritating.”

“Free of” lists. Each maker or its Amazon listing gives its own list of what it leaves out, and the lists differ, so we give them pick by pick. Consumer Reports and Made Safe screened ingredient lists “for known or suspected risks to human and environmental health” and labelled them “No known risks”, “Possible risks” or “Known risks”; we give that label for each pick they covered.

For older children’s hair, see our guides to shampoo for kids and clean shampoo for kids.

Ages and Warnings in the Makers’ Words

Age lines. Babo: “Suitable for babies from birth on.” Aveeno: “suitable for newborns”. Mustela: “Safe from birth on”. We found no age line from Honest, Hello Bello, Weleda, Aquaphor, CeraVe or ATTITUDE for these products. On when to start, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) says: “Only give your newborn sponge baths until the stump of the umbilical cord falls off, which usually happens by about one or two weeks of age.”

Warnings on the bottle or listing:

  • Babo: “CAUTION: For external use only. Avoid contact with eyes.” It recommends a 24-hour patch test on first use and says: “If irritation occurs, stop use and contact your physician.”
  • Honest: “For external use only. Avoid contact with eyes. If contact occurs, flush thoroughly with water. Keep out of reach of children, except under adult supervision.”
  • Hello Bello (Amazon): “DISCONTINUE USE IF RASH, REDNESS, OR ITCHING OCCURS.” and “AVOID CONTACT WITH EYES.”
  • Aveeno: “Keep out of reach of children. Do not use if quality seal is broken or missing.”
  • Aquaphor (Amazon): “For external use only. Avoid contact with eyes.”
  • CeraVe (Amazon): “Excessive use or prolonged exposure may cause irritation to skin and urinary tract. Discontinue if rash, redness, or itching occur.”
  • Mustela’s Amazon listing says: “Always patch-test a small area first.”
  • ATTITUDE (Amazon): “FOR EXTERNAL USE ONLY.”
  • Babo, Hello Bello (Amazon) and CeraVe also say to keep the product out of children’s reach.
  • Weleda’s Amazon safety line reads “Use as directed on label.” Amazon shows a “California’s Proposition 65” warning heading on the Weleda and CeraVe listings; we could not see its text.

In the bath. The AAP says: “Wash baby’s hair two or three times a week using a mild shampoo or body wash.” It adds: “When you rinse shampoo from their head, cup your hand across her forehead so the suds run toward the sides, not into their eyes.” And: “Never leave a baby alone in the bath, even for an instant.” For tubs, see our bath tub guide.

How We Picked These Baby Shampoos

How this guide was built

built from manufacturer pages, Amazon listings, BabyGearLab’s hands-on review, Consumer Reports’ ingredient review and owner forum threads; we have not tested these products ourselves.

What we compared for each shampoo

  • Scent and claims: fragrance-free or scented, tear-free wording and “free of” lists, quoted from the maker.
  • Age and warnings: quoted from the maker’s page or the Amazon listing; we never set an age the maker does not give.
  • Independent views: BabyGearLab’s verdict and Consumer Reports’ ingredient label, where they covered the product.
  • Stock and price: new, in stock and sold by Amazon.com on November 15, 2026, and not above the maker’s own price where one is published.
Sources and recall check and what parents say in forums

Sources and recall check

BabyGearLab, led by a pediatrician, says it bought and tested 10 baby shampoos on babies (review updated June 30, 2025). Consumer Reports and Made Safe analyzed the ingredient lists of 22 baby shampoos. Both earn commissions on retailer links, as we do.

We searched the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission’s recall database and the FDA’s recall listings for all nine brands on November 15, 2026, and found no recall of these shampoos. The FDA lists a 2021 recall of Aveeno aerosol sunscreens, a different product.

We left out Johnson’s Baby Shampoo, which BabyGearLab called a “Disappointing Classic Choice” and Consumer Reports listed under “Worse Choices”, and a Babyganics fragrance-free wash, whose maker page lists “plant-derived fragrance” while its Amazon listing does not.

What parents say in forums

In an r/moderatelygranolamoms thread started on September 26, 2024 (comments dated by the thread’s start), a parent who asked about Pipette, Babo Botanicals Sensitive Baby and Tubby Todd got a reply that names no bottle size: “I’ve tried all 3, and Babo is the one we’re still using on my three year old.” Pipette drew the most mentions in that thread; one parent wrote, “Unpopular opinion I don’t love pipette. The fragrance free has a weird scent.” In an r/beyondthebump thread started on December 31, 2024, parents named Honest, Mustela, ATTITUDE, CeraVe, Johnson’s and others, mostly without naming the exact product.

Detailed Reviews

Babo Botanicals Sensitive Baby Fragrance-Free 2-in-1 Shampoo & Wash, 16 oz, Top Pick

Top Pick
Babo Botanicals Fragrance-Free 2-in-1 Baby Shampoo & Wash…

Babo Sensitive Baby 2-in-1, 16 oz

16 oz · BabyGearLab

Parents who want a fragrance-free wash from birth that an independent reviewer ranked first.

$20.00 from AmazonAs of Nov 15, 20:05 UTC

Verdict

BabyGearLab’s favorite baby shampoo, fragrance-free and, its maker says, “Suitable for babies from birth on.”

Evidence: Independently reviewed, exact model. BabyGearLab: Sensitive Baby Shampoo & Wash, 16 fl oz.

Babo describes it as “Created for babies and kiddos with sensitive skin” and “Made with 23 plant-based ingredients such as oat, cocoa butter and aloe vera”. It lists the formula as free of “Fragrance Sulfates Silicones Mineral Oil Parabens & Phthalates Synthetic Colorants Soy & Dairy”, and calls it “EWG Verified”. Babo does not call it tear-free; its directions say “Avoid the eye area” and suggest a 24-hour patch test before first full use.

BabyGearLab, which tested the 16 fl oz bottle, wrote: “Our favorite shampoo and wash for babies is the Babo Botanicals Sensitive Baby Shampoo & Wash.” It listed “Cost” and “Hard to find in stores” as reasons to avoid it.

Specs (linked: Babo Botanicals Sensitive Baby Fragrance-Free 2-in-1 Shampoo & Wash, 16 oz)

  • Scent: fragrance-free, no essential oils (Babo)
  • Tear-free: not claimed; “Avoid the eye area” (Babo)
  • Age: “from birth on” (Babo)
  • Free of: fragrance, sulfates, silicones, mineral oil, parabens, phthalates, synthetic colorants, soy, dairy (Babo)
  • Seller when checked: Amazon.com, at Babo’s own list price

Pros

  • BabyGearLab’s top-ranked shampoo and wash, fragrance-free
  • Babo says it suits babies from birth
  • Babo’s free-of list includes soy and dairy

Cons

  • The priciest per bottle of the nine when we checked, as BabyGearLab also noted on cost
  • No tear-free claim; Babo says to avoid the eye area

Who should buy it

Parents who want a fragrance-free wash from birth that an independent reviewer ranked first.

Check on Amazon

The Honest Company Shampoo & Body Wash, Lavender Calm, 10 fl oz, Lavender Scented

Lavender Scented

Verdict

A tear-free 2-in-1 with lavender essential oils for parents who want a light scent.

Evidence: Independently reviewed, same series. BabyGearLab: Truly Calming Lavender Shampoo and Wash, 10 fl oz (earlier label).

Honest says it is “Tear-free and gentle for babe, but great for the whole fam”, calls it “Hypoallergenic” and “Dermatologist Tested”, and lists it “Made with chamomile extract, aloe and other naturally derived fragrance”. It is made without “Parabens, Phthalates, Synthetic Fragrances, Formaldehyde Donors, and SLS/SLES”. The ingredient list includes lavender oils and linalool.

BabyGearLab named an earlier Honest lavender 10 fl oz label, “Honest Truly Calming Lavender Shampoo and Wash”, its “Best Bang for the Buck” and wrote: “The lavender scent is lovely, not overpowering like some contenders, and we like the bottle’s pump dispenser.”

Specs (linked: The Honest Company Shampoo & Body Wash, Lavender Calm, 10 fl oz)

  • Scent: lavender, from essential oils (Honest)
  • Tear-free: yes (Honest)
  • Age: none given; “gentle for babe” (Honest)
  • Free of: parabens, phthalates, synthetic fragrances, formaldehyde donors, SLS/SLES (Honest)
  • Seller when checked: Amazon.com, below Honest’s list price

Pros

  • Tear-free and lightly scented with lavender (Honest; BabyGearLab)
  • BabyGearLab’s value pick in an earlier label
  • Honest pitches it for the whole family

Cons

  • Scented: lavender oils and linalool are on the ingredient list
  • No age line from Honest

Who should buy it

Parents who want a tear-free wash with a light lavender scent.

Check on Amazon

Hello Bello Baby Shampoo & Body Wash, Fragrance Free, 10 oz, Gluten and Dairy Free

Gluten and Dairy Free
Hello Bello Baby Shampoo & Body Wash, Gentle Fragrance…

Hello Bello Shampoo & Wash, Fragrance Free

Fragrance Free, 10 oz · BabyGearLab

Parents who want a fragrance-free wash without gluten, peanut or dairy on the maker's list.

$9.97 from AmazonAs of Nov 15, 20:05 UTC

Verdict

A fragrance-free 2-in-1 whose maker lists gluten, peanut and dairy among what it leaves out.

Evidence: Independently reviewed, previous generation. BabyGearLab: Extra Gentle, earlier formula, 10 fl oz.

Hello Bello sells this formula as “Baby Ultra-Hydrating Shampoo & Wash”, made with “Avocado and Calendula extracts” and “Jojoba Seed Oil”. It is “formulated without dyes, sulfates, parabens, phthalates, phenoxyethanol, synthetic fragrances, formaldehyde donors, or common allergens like gluten, peanut, or dairy.” Its product page also shows a “Tear-free” badge.

BabyGearLab tested the earlier “Hello Bello Extra Gentle” version and noted: “Hello Bello released this product with a new formula, but it’s still fragrance-free and designed for sensitive skin.” Consumer Reports rated “Hello Bello Baby Shampoo & Wash, Fragrance Free” as “Possible risks”, without saying which version.

Specs (linked: Hello Bello Baby Shampoo & Body Wash, Fragrance Free, 10 oz)

  • Scent: fragrance-free (Hello Bello)
  • Tear-free: “Tear-free” badge (Hello Bello)
  • Age: none given
  • Free of: dyes, sulfates, parabens, phthalates, phenoxyethanol, synthetic fragrances, formaldehyde donors, gluten, peanut, dairy (Hello Bello)
  • Seller when checked: Amazon.com, below Hello Bello’s list price

Pros

  • Maker’s free-of list names gluten, peanut and dairy
  • Fragrance-free (Hello Bello)
  • Entry-level price when we checked

Cons

  • BabyGearLab tested the earlier formula, not this one
  • Consumer Reports’ label: “Possible risks”

Who should buy it

Parents who want a fragrance-free wash without gluten, peanut or dairy on the maker’s list.

Check on Amazon

Aveeno Baby Daily Moisture Wash & Shampoo, 18 fl oz, Oat Extract Wash

Oat Extract Wash
Aveeno Baby Daily Moisture Wash & Shampoo, Tear-Free, 18…

Aveeno Baby Daily Moisture Wash, 18 oz

18 fl oz · CR

Parents who want a tear-free wash its maker says suits newborns and don't mind a light scent.

$12.62 from AmazonAs of Nov 15, 20:05 UTC

Verdict

A lightly scented, tear-free wash with oat extract that Aveeno calls “suitable for newborns”.

Evidence: Independently reviewed, same series. Consumer Reports and Made Safe: Daily Moisture Wash & Shampoo, size not stated.

Aveeno says it is “Made for babies with sensitive skin and suitable for newborns”, “Tear-free and hypoallergenic” and “Formulated without soap, parabens, sulfates, or phthalates”, and that it leaves “a light, fresh scent”. “Fragrance” is on the ingredient list. The maker’s warning reads: “Keep out of reach of children. Do not use if quality seal is broken or missing.”

Consumer Reports put “Aveeno Baby Daily Moisture Wash & Shampoo” in its “Good Choices” group, labelled “Possible risks”. Amazon showed “Only 10 left in stock” for this size when we checked. Amazon’s 12 fl oz listing shows “Manufacturer recommended age: 12 months – 10 years”, which conflicts with Aveeno’s own page; we link the 18 fl oz.

Specs (linked: Aveeno Baby Daily Moisture Wash & Shampoo, 18 fl oz)

  • Scent: light, fresh scent; contains fragrance (Aveeno)
  • Tear-free: yes (Aveeno)
  • Age: “suitable for newborns” (Aveeno)
  • Free of: soap, parabens, sulfates, phthalates (Aveeno)
  • Seller when checked: Amazon.com; Aveeno publishes no list price

Pros

  • Tear-free, with Aveeno’s newborn line
  • Oat extract formula in an 18 fl oz bottle
  • In Consumer Reports’ “Good Choices” group

Cons

  • Scented, with fragrance on the ingredient list
  • Low stock on this size when we checked

Who should buy it

Parents who want a tear-free wash its maker says suits newborns and don’t mind a light scent.

Check on Amazon

Weleda Baby Calendula 2-in-1 Shampoo and Body Wash, 6.8 fl oz, Calendula Formula

Calendula Formula
Weleda Baby Calendula 2-in-1 Gentle Shampoo and Body Wash…

Weleda Calendula 2-in-1, 6.8 oz

6.8 fl oz · BabyGearLab

Parents who like a plant-oil formula with a soft calendula scent.

$10.41 from AmazonAs of Nov 15, 20:05 UTC

Verdict

A plant-oil wash with calendula and sweet almond oil, lightly scented, in a 6.8 fl oz bottle.

Evidence: Independently reviewed, exact model. BabyGearLab: Baby 2-in-1 Shampoo and Body Wash, 6.8 fl oz.

Weleda says “the soft lather doesn’t sting baby’s eyes” and that the wash is “Dermatologically proven very skin-friendly, even on sensitive skin and cradle-cap.” Its ingredient list includes sesame seed oil, sweet almond oil and “Fragrance (Parfum)”. Weleda adds: “Also, suitable for adults with sensitive skin.”

BabyGearLab, which tested this 6.8 fl oz bottle, liked its “Subtle scent” and “Nice lather” and wrote: “One drawback is that this product does not offer a pump dispenser but a flip-top.”

Specs (linked: Weleda Baby Calendula 2-in-1 Shampoo and Body Wash, 6.8 fl oz)

  • Scent: calendula; “Fragrance (Parfum)” listed (Weleda)
  • Tear-free: “gentle on eyes” (Weleda)
  • Age: none given
  • Contains: sesame seed oil, sweet almond oil (Weleda)
  • Seller when checked: Amazon.com, below Weleda’s list price

Pros

  • Calendula and sweet almond oil formula (Weleda)
  • Weleda says the lather “doesn’t sting baby’s eyes”
  • BabyGearLab noted a subtle scent and nice lather

Cons

  • Flip-top cap, not a pump (BabyGearLab)
  • Sesame and almond oils are on the ingredient list

Who should buy it

Parents who like a plant-oil formula with a soft calendula scent.

Check on Amazon

Aquaphor Baby Wash and Shampoo, 25.4 fl oz, Large Pump Bottle

Large Pump Bottle
Aquaphor Baby Body Wash and Shampoo, 25.4 FL OZ | Tear Free…

Aquaphor Baby Wash and Shampoo, 25.4 oz

25.4 fl oz · BabyGearLab

Parents who want a big fragrance-free bottle they can pump with one hand.

$12.97 from AmazonAs of Nov 15, 20:05 UTC

Verdict

The biggest bottle in this guide, fragrance-free, with a pump Aquaphor calls “Convenient pump dispenser for one-handed use”.

Evidence: Independently reviewed, exact model. BabyGearLab: Baby Wash and Shampoo, 25.4 fl oz.

Aquaphor lists “Chamomile essence and Provitamin B5” and says the wash “Washes hair without irritating the scalp”. Its page calls it “Preservative and fragrance free”, while the same page’s ingredient list, like Amazon’s, includes sodium benzoate. Amazon’s listing calls it tear-free and warns: “For external use only. Avoid contact with eyes.”

BabyGearLab tested the 25.4 fl oz bottle and wrote: “We are unsure if this shampoo is phthalate-free because the product’s packaging lacks clarity on this detail.”

Specs (linked: Aquaphor Baby Wash and Shampoo, 25.4 fl oz)

  • Scent: fragrance-free (Aquaphor)
  • Tear-free: per the Amazon listing
  • Age: none given
  • Free of: fragrance, parabens, dyes (Amazon listing)
  • Seller when checked: Amazon.com; Aquaphor publishes no list price

Pros

  • 25.4 fl oz, the largest bottle of the nine
  • Pump for one-handed use (Aquaphor)
  • Fragrance-free (Aquaphor)

Cons

  • No phthalate statement, BabyGearLab noted
  • Aquaphor’s “Preservative and fragrance free” line sits beside sodium benzoate on its own ingredient list

Who should buy it

Parents who want a big fragrance-free bottle they can pump with one hand.

Check on Amazon

CeraVe Baby Wash & Shampoo, 8 oz, Eczema Association Seal

Eczema Association Seal
CeraVe Baby 2-in-1 Wash & Shampoo with Vitamin E for Hair &…

CeraVe Baby Wash & Shampoo, 8 oz

8 oz · BabyGearLab

Parents who want a fragrance-free wash carrying the National Eczema Association's seal.

$8.97 from AmazonAs of Nov 15, 20:05 UTC

Verdict

A fragrance-free, tear-free wash with ceramides that CeraVe says is “Accepted by the National Eczema Association”.

Evidence: Independently reviewed, exact model. BabyGearLab: Baby Wash and Shampoo, 8 fl oz.

CeraVe calls it a “fragrance-free, soap-free, tear-free formula with three essential ceramides”, “developed with pediatric dermatologists”, and “free of parabens, phthalates, sulfates, dyes and fragrance”. Its maker page warns: “Avoid contact with eyes. In case of eye contact, rinse immediately and thoroughly. Keep out of reach of children. Do not swallow.” For itchy scalps in older kids, see our itchy scalp shampoo guide.

The independent views split. BabyGearLab tested the 8 fl oz bottle and wrote: “In our experience, this product leaves hair oily, regardless of an increased effort to thoroughly wash and rinse.” Consumer Reports listed “CeraVe Baby Wash & Shampoo” under “Worse Choices”, labelled “Known risks”.

Specs (linked: CeraVe Baby Wash & Shampoo, 8 oz)

  • Scent: fragrance-free (CeraVe)
  • Tear-free: yes (CeraVe)
  • Age: none given
  • Free of: parabens, phthalates, sulfates, dyes, fragrance (CeraVe)
  • Seller when checked: Amazon.com, below CeraVe’s list price

Pros

  • National Eczema Association acceptance, per CeraVe
  • Ceramides, hyaluronic acid and vitamin E (CeraVe)
  • Fragrance-free and tear-free (CeraVe)

Cons

  • BabyGearLab found it left hair oily
  • Consumer Reports’ label: “Known risks”

Who should buy it

Parents who want a fragrance-free wash carrying the National Eczema Association’s seal.

Check on Amazon

Mustela Foam Shampoo for Newborns, 5.07 fl oz, Cradle Cap Foam

Cradle Cap Foam
Mustela Foam Shampoo for Newborns - Baby Shampoo for Cradle…

Mustela Foam Shampoo for Newborns

5.07 fl oz · CR

Parents of a newborn with cradle cap who want a foam shampoo for the scalp.

$16.50 from AmazonAs of Nov 15, 20:05 UTC

Verdict

A fragrance-free foam shampoo for cradle cap that Mustela labels “Safe from birth on”, in Consumer Reports’ top group.

Evidence: Independently reviewed, exact model. Consumer Reports and Made Safe: Foam Shampoo for Newborns (one size).

Mustela says it “minimizes cradle cap, exfoliates flakes, and helps prevent recurrence”, is “Gentle on eyes” and “Fragrance-free”, and is free from “parabens, phthalates, phenoxyethanol, and 1,700+ EU-banned ingredients”. It cites a “Clinical study carried out under dermatological and pediatric supervision on 38 children with cradle cap”. Mustela suggests daily use “during cradle-cap flare-ups, then 2–3 times weekly”. Amazon’s listing adds: “Always patch-test a small area first.”

Consumer Reports put “Mustela Foam Shampoo for Newborns” in “Top Choices”, labelled “No known risks”. BabyGearLab reviewed a 5.07 fl oz “Mustela Baby Foam Shampoo for Cradle Cap” as “Limited Use for Cradle Cap”; we could not confirm it is this formula. On cradle cap itself, the AAP calls it “a harmless condition that appears in many babies” and adds: “You can loosen the scales with a soft-bristled brush while shampooing in the bathtub, but it’s also okay to leave it alone if it doesn’t bother you. It’s unlikely to bother your baby, and they will outgrow it.”

Specs (linked: Mustela Foam Shampoo for Newborns, 5.07 fl oz)

  • Scent: fragrance-free (Mustela)
  • Tear-free: “Gentle on eyes” (Mustela)
  • Age: “Safe from birth on” (Mustela)
  • Free of: parabens, phthalates, phenoxyethanol (Mustela)
  • Seller when checked: Amazon.com, at Mustela’s own list price

Pros

  • Made for cradle cap, per Mustela, with its own small study
  • Mustela says it is for use from birth
  • “No known risks” from Consumer Reports and Made Safe

Cons

  • Smallest bottle of the nine at 5.07 fl oz
  • A scalp shampoo, not a 2-in-1 body wash

Who should buy it

Parents of a newborn with cradle cap who want a foam shampoo for the scalp.

Check on Amazon

ATTITUDE Baby Foaming Shampoo & Body Wash, Unscented, 10 fl oz, Unscented Foam Pump

Unscented Foam Pump
ATTITUDE Baby Shampoo & Body Wash Foaming 2-in-1…

ATTITUDE Foaming 2-in-1, Unscented

Unscented, 10 fl oz · CR

Parents who want an unscented foam they can pump with one hand while holding the baby.

$8.99 from AmazonAs of Nov 15, 20:05 UTC

Verdict

An unscented wash that pumps out as ready-made foam, in Consumer Reports’ top group under an earlier name.

Evidence: Independently reviewed, same series. Consumer Reports and Made Safe: Baby Leaves Hair & Body Foaming Wash, Unscented (earlier name), size not stated.

ATTITUDE’s Amazon listing says “READY-MADE FOAM, ONE HAND FREE” and “No added fragrance and no masking scent at all”. It lists the formula as “Free from parabens, methylisothiazolinone (MIT), formaldehyde releasers, phthalates, SLES, petrolatum and artificial dyes”, “EWG VERIFIED” and “dermatologically tested”. The listing’s safety line reads “FOR EXTERNAL USE ONLY.” We found no age line for this foaming version.

Consumer Reports listed “Attitude Baby Leaves Hair & Body Foaming Wash, Unscented” in “Top Choices”, labelled “No known risks”; that is an earlier product name, and the review gives no size. We found no page for this foaming wash on ATTITUDE’s U.S. site.

Specs (linked: ATTITUDE Baby Foaming Shampoo & Body Wash, Unscented, 10 fl oz)

  • Scent: unscented, no added fragrance (ATTITUDE listing)
  • Tear-free: not claimed
  • Age: none given
  • Free of: parabens, MIT, formaldehyde releasers, phthalates, SLES, petrolatum, artificial dyes (ATTITUDE listing)
  • Seller when checked: Amazon.com; no maker list price found

Pros

  • Pumps out as foam for one-handed washing (ATTITUDE)
  • Unscented, with no masking scent (ATTITUDE)
  • “No known risks” from Consumer Reports under an earlier name

Cons

  • No age line found for this version
  • No page on ATTITUDE’s U.S. site to check claims against

Who should buy it

Parents who want an unscented foam they can pump with one hand while holding the baby.

Check on Amazon

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. What is the most recommended baby shampoo?

No single shampoo tops every source. BabyGearLab’s favorite is Babo Botanicals Sensitive Baby Shampoo & Wash. Consumer Reports and Made Safe’s “Top Choices” include Mustela Foam Shampoo for Newborns and an unscented ATTITUDE foaming wash. In two forum threads we read, parents named Babo, Pipette, Honest and Mustela among others.

Q. What is the best baby shampoo for babies?

It depends on what you want to avoid. For no scent, the six fragrance-free or unscented picks above; for a light scent, Honest, Aveeno or Weleda. BabyGearLab says: “Babies require a special baby-specific shampoo, and using an adult shampoo or whatever is in your shower might cause unnecessary irritation to new eyes and delicate skin.”

Q. What is the best newborn baby shampoo?

Three makers here give a newborn or birth age line: Babo (“from birth on”), Aveeno (“suitable for newborns”) and Mustela (“Safe from birth on”). The AAP advises sponge baths until the umbilical cord stump falls off and says “Three baths per week during baby’s first year may be enough.”

Q. What is the best rated baby wash?

Ratings depend on the reviewer. BabyGearLab ranked Babo first of the 10 it tested. Consumer Reports rates ingredient lists, not cleaning, and gave Mustela’s newborn foam and an ATTITUDE unscented foaming wash its best label, “No known risks”. Amazon star ratings are written by buyers and are not independent tests.

The bottom line

Final Verdict

Babo Botanicals Sensitive Baby Fragrance-Free 2-in-1 Shampoo & Wash, 16 oz (check price) is our top pick: fragrance-free, BabyGearLab’s favorite and labelled by Babo for use from birth. Choose Aveeno for a tear-free wash with a light scent, Aquaphor for the biggest pump bottle, Mustela for cradle cap, CeraVe for the eczema association’s seal, ATTITUDE for unscented foam, Honest for lavender, Hello Bello for its gluten- and dairy-free list, and Weleda for calendula.

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Kids Save the World Team
Kids Save the World Team

Written and reviewed by the Kids Save the World Team. See the About page for how we work.